• About
  • Archive
  • China Business Review Historical Archive
  • Contact
  • Home 1
  • Submit a Story
  • Submit a Story
  • USCBC Podcasts
China Business Review
  • Operations
    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

  • Politics
    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    A Game of Chicken

    A Game of Chicken

  • Tech
    China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

    China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    Trending Tags

    • Intellectual Property
    • innovation
    • cybersecurity
    • ecommerce
    • tech
  • Society
    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    Open Government Developments in China: Implications for US Businesses

  • Media

    Gallery: Craig Allen’s Trip to China

    USCBC 45th Annual Membership Meeting

    USCBC 45th Anniversary DC Open House

    USCBC President’s China Visit

    USCBC Hosts Business Roundtable with Zhejiang Party Secretary Che Jun

    USCBC hosts Comprehensive Economic Dialogue (CED) Luncheon

  • Podcasts
  • Archive
No Result
View All Result
  • Operations
    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

  • Politics
    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    A Game of Chicken

    A Game of Chicken

  • Tech
    China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

    China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    Trending Tags

    • Intellectual Property
    • innovation
    • cybersecurity
    • ecommerce
    • tech
  • Society
    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    Open Government Developments in China: Implications for US Businesses

  • Media

    Gallery: Craig Allen’s Trip to China

    USCBC 45th Annual Membership Meeting

    USCBC 45th Anniversary DC Open House

    USCBC President’s China Visit

    USCBC Hosts Business Roundtable with Zhejiang Party Secretary Che Jun

    USCBC hosts Comprehensive Economic Dialogue (CED) Luncheon

  • Podcasts
  • Archive
No Result
View All Result
China Business Review
No Result
View All Result
Home Politics

Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

Anna Ashton and Allie Klein by Anna Ashton and Allie Klein
September 22, 2020
Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterLinkedin

Last month, WTO Director-General Roberto Azevedo resigned from his role leading the World Trade Organization (WTO) a full year before his second 4-year term was scheduled to end. Azevedo’s surprise announcement this spring underscored mounting dysfunction in the global trading system just as the massive economic toll of the COVID-19 pandemic and the challenges of developing an international response were coming into focus. A new leader—to be selected this fall—will have the high-stakes task of reforming the organization and restoring its global relevance while navigating the deteriorating relationship between the WTO’s two largest member economies.

As if to hammer this point home, days before Azevedo’s official resignation, US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer warned that world trade may soon be governed by “pure bilateralism,” an eventuality he said the United States is prepared to accept unless the World Trade Organization undertakes urgent, fundamental reforms. President Trump has explicitly threatened more than once to pull the United States out of the WTO, a path that some members of Congress have also sought to pursue. The perspective that the WTO is in desperate need of mending, however, predates protectionist views held by the Trump administration and is shared even by US policymakers who strongly oppose a US withdrawal, as well as by many other WTO member state leaders.

Dueling reform priorities

The WTO has struggled to find a solution that effectively addresses the incompatibilities between free market competition and Chinese state capitalism.

The US agenda

The United States asserts that the “centrality of market orientation” is a fundamental WTO principle that all members should be required to uphold. Reforms to this end could include strengthening remedies for unfair advantages that China’s state subsidies afford and closing loopholes that allow China to designate itself a developing country and benefit from the special accommodations that come with that status. The United States has been pursuing a trilateral effort with the EU and Japan since 2017 to strongly curtail allowable subsidies and state supports, many of which have been central to China’s economic success. However, progress has been slow and any agreement reached between the three parties would still require acceptance by other WTO members including China.

The United States’ frustration with the current WTO system is most evident in its refusal since the Obama administration to approve judges to serve on the Appellate Body, a quorum of judges that preside over dispute cases between members. Of the 20 completed cases the United States has filed against China, 11 cases were won by the United States and nine were settled before a ruling was made. None were lost. Despite this track record, the United States contends that the WTO Appellate Body has habitually issued rulings that dictate the terms of international trade law well beyond the scope of what WTO member countries envisioned. Washington wants a reformed WTO to deemphasize dispute litigation and refocus members’ energies on productive negotiation.

China’s agenda

China contends that WTO reforms should be aimed at curbing unilateral sanctions, long-arm jurisdiction, and abuse of national security exceptions to trade rules. And as allies and neighbors as close to the United States as Canada can attest, China is not alone in its umbrage at being subjected to US trade measures it sees as protectionism wrapped in national security pretenses. China insists that the WTO should accommodate different economic development models, and argues rule changes that would disable critical aspects of its model are designed to undermine its competitiveness rather than make competition more fair.

When it comes to the Appellate Body, China argues that the body, along with the dispute resolution system, are critical pillars of the WTO. China has contended that the greatest and most imminent institutional risk to the dispute settlement’s effectiveness is the United States’ refusal to approve judges.

Decisive leadership required of the next director-general

There are five contenders for the director-general post, hailing from Nigeria, South Korea, Kenya, Saudi Arabia, and the UK. There will be two more rounds of consultations before a selection is made, with the next round set to end on October 6. Nigerian former World Bank Managing Director Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala and Kenyan former Trade Minister Amina Mohamed are viewed by many analysts as the front runners, in part because their African states are seen as less clearly aligned with either major power. This has given rise to hopes that either of the two women would be well-positioned to broker disagreements between the world’s two most powerful economies. Mohamed has something of a track record to that end. She successfully mediated differences between China and the United States during the 10th WTO ministerial meeting in 2015 to reach a major agreement abolishing certain subsidies for farm exports.

But the stakes are high. Former World Bank President Robert Zoellick and former WTO Director-General Pascal Lamy told a Washington audience on September 10 that the WTO will be irrelevant in 5 years if it does not demonstrate an ability to successfully craft and implement new rules and reforms. Key among the needed reforms, both said, are persuading China to accept new disciplines on state subsidies and persuading the United States to stop “hijacking” the dispute settlement system. But any director-general candidate who faces strong opposition from either of the two leading trade powers or does not have the right experience to manage tense political conflict is unlikely to land the job, making it hard for serious contenders to embrace  strong and meaningful reforms.

Anna Ashton, senior director of government affairs at the US-China Business Council, has previously served as a China analyst for the Department of Defense, US Chamber of Commerce, and US-China Economic and Security Review Commission. 

Allie Klein is a government affairs intern at the US-China Business Council.

Photo licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0

Anna Ashton and Allie Klein

Anna Ashton and Allie Klein

Next Post
China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

Recommended.

China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

August 5, 2022

Reflections on the Phase One Agreement

January 20, 2022

Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

November 29, 2021

From Reshoring to Rightshoring: Dr. Sara Hsu on the Future of US-China Supply Chains

August 4, 2021

Latest Podcasts.

What recent chip export controls mean for business

January 25, 2023

Taking stock as we enter USCBC’s 50th year

January 13, 2023

What unexpected midterm results mean for China policy

November 16, 2022

Two tales of travel to China

November 7, 2022
China Business Review

China Business Review is the official magazine of the US-China Business Council, a nonprofit and nonpartisan trade association that represents more than 200 American companies doing business in China.

  • How to contribute to China Business Review

Categories

  • Bilateral Relations
  • Business Etiquette
  • CBR Spotlight
  • China Deals
  • Corruption
  • Cybersecurity
  • Ecommerce
  • Environment
  • Finance
  • Galleries
  • Getting Started
  • HR & Staffing
  • Infographics
  • Innovation
  • Intellectual Property
  • Management
  • Media
  • Operations
  • Opinion
  • Policy & Regulations
  • Politics
  • PR & Marketing
  • Rural Issues
  • Safety
  • Social Policy
  • Society
  • Standards + Licensing
  • Sustainability
  • Tax
  • Tech
  • Top Story
  • Trade
  • Uncategorized
  • US-China Business Council
  • Videos

Tags

Agreements Agriculture Alibaba Best Practices Business Environment China China's Investments Abroad China Market Intelligence Chinese Consumers Chinese Investment Commentary Consumer Trends E-Commerce Economic Trends Energy Environment Events Food Foreign Investment Going Global Healthcare Reform Human Resources Infrastructure Internet Interview Investment Investments into China IPO Joint Venture Labor Legal Analysis M&A Manufacturing Media National People's Congress Q&A Strategic and Economic Dialogue Supply Chains Technology Trade Transparency US-China Relations USCBC US Exports to China Xi Jinping

Join our Mailing List

Sign up for the US-China Business Council's newsletters to stay ahead of the game with roundups, analysis, and commentary.

Sign Up

Follow Us

  • About
  • USCBC
  • Submit a Story
  • Archive

© 2022 China Business Review

No Result
View All Result
  • Operations
  • Politics
  • Tech
  • Society
  • Media
  • Podcasts
  • Archive

© 2022 China Business Review