• About
  • Archive
  • China Business Review Historical Archive
  • Contact
  • Home 1
  • Submit a Story
  • Submit a Story
  • USCBC Podcasts
China Business Review
  • Operations
    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

  • Politics
    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    A Game of Chicken

    A Game of Chicken

  • Tech
    China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

    China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    Trending Tags

    • Intellectual Property
    • innovation
    • cybersecurity
    • ecommerce
    • tech
  • Society
    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    Open Government Developments in China: Implications for US Businesses

  • Media

    Gallery: Craig Allen’s Trip to China

    USCBC 45th Annual Membership Meeting

    USCBC 45th Anniversary DC Open House

    USCBC President’s China Visit

    USCBC Hosts Business Roundtable with Zhejiang Party Secretary Che Jun

    USCBC hosts Comprehensive Economic Dialogue (CED) Luncheon

  • Podcasts
  • Archive
No Result
View All Result
  • Operations
    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Multinational Supply Chains in a Post-Pandemic China

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Managing Risk in the “New Era”

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    Design Patents vs. Trade Dress: Protecting IP in China

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    As China Emerges from COVID-19, US Companies Invest to Compete

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Inside the Mad Rush for Masks – Anatomy of a 10 Million Mask Order

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

    Addressing Risk in the Era of US-China “Great Power” Competition

  • Politics
    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    Hong Kong’s National Security Law, Five Months In

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    China Implements its Long-Awaited Unreliable Entities List Mechanism

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    Competing WTO Reform Agendas and the Contest for the Next Director-General

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    China Eyes Further Northeast Asian Economic Integration in RCEP

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    A Game of Chicken

    A Game of Chicken

  • Tech
    China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

    China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    Semiconductor Self-Sufficiency: MIIT’s Ambitions for 2021 and Beyond

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    The Growing Intersection of Digital Health and Data Processing in China

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    Export Controls on Emerging and Foundational Technologies: A Null Set?

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    How Companies Are Reacting to China’s New Data Security Scheme

    Trending Tags

    • Intellectual Property
    • innovation
    • cybersecurity
    • ecommerce
    • tech
  • Society
    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    China Cracks Down on Education Industry in Effort to Increase Birthrate

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    The Extraordinary Rise of China’s Pet Industry

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    COVID-19 Could Doom or Deliver US-China Commercial Relations

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    The Year in Social Credit: Where is Corporate Social Credit Going in 2020 and Beyond?

    Open Government Developments in China: Implications for US Businesses

  • Media

    Gallery: Craig Allen’s Trip to China

    USCBC 45th Annual Membership Meeting

    USCBC 45th Anniversary DC Open House

    USCBC President’s China Visit

    USCBC Hosts Business Roundtable with Zhejiang Party Secretary Che Jun

    USCBC hosts Comprehensive Economic Dialogue (CED) Luncheon

  • Podcasts
  • Archive
No Result
View All Result
China Business Review
No Result
View All Result
Home Bilateral Relations

2 WTO Complaints, 11 Raw Materials, and 1 Approaching Deadline

Nicole Golliher by Nicole Golliher
October 24, 2016
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterLinkedin

By Nicole Golliher

The European Union and the United States in July filed with the World Trade Organization (WTO) new disputes against China regarding its raw materials export duties. Both complaints claim China export duties unfairly favor Chinese industry, which is against the laws of the organization.  

These complaints were filed just months before the 15-year anniversary of China’s entry into the WTO, and the deadline to remove China’s non-market status. What they must do beyond this, however, is controversial. While China argues that countries must grant it market economy status, the agreement does not specify that requirement. And as the deadline looms, many in the United States and the EU are worried about protecting themselves from overcapacity, especially in steel.

The complaints

The EU launched a complaint July 19 that China failed to remove export duties on 11 raw materials (graphite, copper, cobalt, lead), a violation of its WTO commitments. China is the main exporter of raw materials essential to EU industry and export duties on these goods makes them cheaper to purchase in China than abroad.

The  EU has brought three cases against China in its 15-year WTO membership; in that same time, the United States has brought 13 disputes, including a recent case that mirrors the EU complaint.

The July 13 US dispute  cites China’s 5-20 percent export duties on nine raw materials:  antimony, cobalt, copper, graphite, lead, magnesia, talc, tantalum, and tin. These goods affect vital US industries, such as automobiles, electronics, and chemicals.

China says its export duties are consistent with WTO rules, a claim that will be decided by the WTO. So far, the United States has won every dispute it has filed, including 12 cases against China. If the WTO finds China in violation of its rules, China must comply or face retaliatory measures, such as trade sanctions.

Dispute resolution: Its function and effect

The WTO can judge trade disputes on the basis of its trade agreements, and member countries are obligated to bring disputes to the organization rather than unilaterally act. A WTO ruling determines which country is just and outlines acceptable courses of action for both parties to resolve the dispute. Of the 400 cases brought before the WTO since 1995, less than 4 percent resulted in sanctions, which highlights the high compliance rate.

The results are mixed. On one hand, WTO  provides an outlet for trade disputes that averts unilateral actions and reduces tit-for-tat protectionism. On the other hand, it’s clear that even when used, it does not automatically remove the problem. The concurrent current cases by the United States and EU illustrate this since they closely mirror previous cases against China.

This month, the Office of the US Trade Representative lead a hearing examining the effect of China’s WTO admission. Erin Ennis, senior vice president of the US-China Business Council (USCBC), served as a witness to the panel. Ennis said “On balance, China’s WTO entry has been positive,” calling the United States’ ability to use a rules-based system to hold China accountable for its commitments a major positive.

Implications of these challenges

The important aspect of these challenges is the timing. Both complaints were filed as concerns about China’s protectionism are on the rise and the United States and EU grapple with the December deadline for China’s NME Status. The United States and the EU worry that dropping China’s NME designation will hinder their ability to address market distortions, including export duties and overcapacity in steel and other industries.

To uphold its commitments, the EU Commission plans  to drop the NME designation, but sidestep the question of market-economy status. This would address the concerns of some countries and industries while adhering to international legal commitments. The commission states that its plan would “allow for high tariffs to be imposed on imports deemed to be priced below international-market levels and accelerate anti-dumping procedures.” The EU has already placed new export duties on Chinese steel, foreshadowing this strategy.

Europe isn’t united on this strategy; there’s ongoing debate among those who want to be tough on China, like Italy, and Nordic countries who think granting China full status and will encourage it to engage more with the European economy.

The United States wants a level playing field. Many policy makers argue that dropping China’s NME status would hamper the United States’ ability to fix market distortions, but that’s not the case. Just because the United States must drop China’s NME status, doesn’t mean it must adopt a market economy status. Like the EU, the United States can adopt a flexible approach that would enable it to address market distortions, like China’s overcapacity or protectionist measures, while upholding its international commitments.

Nicole Golliher

Nicole Golliher

Next Post

City Spotlight: Investing in Hangzhou

Recommended.

China and CPTPP: Does China’s Emerging Data Regime Live Up to CPTPP Principles?

August 5, 2022

Reflections on the Phase One Agreement

January 20, 2022

Can China’s Beleaguered Gaming Industry Overcome the New Wave of Restrictions?

November 29, 2021

From Reshoring to Rightshoring: Dr. Sara Hsu on the Future of US-China Supply Chains

August 4, 2021

Latest Podcasts.

What recent chip export controls mean for business

January 25, 2023

Taking stock as we enter USCBC’s 50th year

January 13, 2023

What unexpected midterm results mean for China policy

November 16, 2022

Two tales of travel to China

November 7, 2022
China Business Review

China Business Review is the official magazine of the US-China Business Council, a nonprofit and nonpartisan trade association that represents more than 200 American companies doing business in China.

  • How to contribute to China Business Review

Categories

  • Bilateral Relations
  • Business Etiquette
  • CBR Spotlight
  • China Deals
  • Corruption
  • Cybersecurity
  • Ecommerce
  • Environment
  • Finance
  • Galleries
  • Getting Started
  • HR & Staffing
  • Infographics
  • Innovation
  • Intellectual Property
  • Management
  • Media
  • Operations
  • Opinion
  • Policy & Regulations
  • Politics
  • PR & Marketing
  • Rural Issues
  • Safety
  • Social Policy
  • Society
  • Standards + Licensing
  • Sustainability
  • Tax
  • Tech
  • Top Story
  • Trade
  • Uncategorized
  • US-China Business Council
  • Videos

Tags

Agreements Agriculture Alibaba Best Practices Business Environment China China's Investments Abroad China Market Intelligence Chinese Consumers Chinese Investment Commentary Consumer Trends E-Commerce Economic Trends Energy Environment Events Food Foreign Investment Going Global Healthcare Reform Human Resources Infrastructure Internet Interview Investment Investments into China IPO Joint Venture Labor Legal Analysis M&A Manufacturing Media National People's Congress Q&A Strategic and Economic Dialogue Supply Chains Technology Trade Transparency US-China Relations USCBC US Exports to China Xi Jinping

Join our Mailing List

Sign up for the US-China Business Council's newsletters to stay ahead of the game with roundups, analysis, and commentary.

Sign Up

Follow Us

  • About
  • USCBC
  • Submit a Story
  • Archive

© 2022 China Business Review

No Result
View All Result
  • Operations
  • Politics
  • Tech
  • Society
  • Media
  • Podcasts
  • Archive

© 2022 China Business Review